Cherry Beat - Recording Sessions (Part Fifteen - The Band's First Reunion)

August 1998
Fourteen years after the band split up, the leaders of the band Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby got together to discuss a possible band reunion. All those past years without playing together as a group had certainly seemed to ease the tensions that had happened between them in the late 70's - early 80's.

While they knew that a band reunion would not be easy, they felt that it could certainly be possible, provided they were willing to work together, and provided they were able to get some additional s to play, unless either Torquil Dohrn, the band's longstanding lead guitarist, or Devon O'Connell, the band's longstanding were willing to rejoin the band.

Both fellow ex-members of were invited to rejoin the group, but both Torquil and Devon turned down the opportunity to rejoin. With Gregory Dogan back as the band's, and Chudley Maron - who was also the band's original producer - back as the band's , the band knew that until they could find more band members to join, they would need to either play all the themselves via , or employ s.

8th September 1998
With Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby back together as a group, the band held their first recording session in over fourteen years on this day. As a warm up, they recorded a couple of s on this day, instead of original compositions.

The said recordings were a cover of a song '' written by  and originally recorded by. And an old 50's song '' which was written and originally recorded by.

'Rock This Town' was completed on this day, while future overdubs would be needed to complete 'Judy Drownded'.

The main reason 'Judy Drownded' wasn't completed on this day was because the band was unsure exactly what instruments were played in the original recording, and they felt that to record a decent version of their own, they needed to use a similar lineup of instruments.

Luther Canup and Percy Duncan, two session musicians that had previously performed on certain past recordings would play on the band's recordings of 'Rock This Town' and 'Judy Drownded'.

6th October 1998
A handful of session musicians were brought in to add additional instrumentation and backing vocals to 'Judy Drownded' on this day. Most of these session musicians had never performed on a recording before, but there were a few familiar faces from previous recordings.

25th October 1998
British musician Milford Ekdahl is now officially a new member of, in which he joined as a and. As Peter and Sam both pointed out, Milford wasn't involved in the group's original incarnation, so he had nothing to do with the conflicts and tension that resulted in our breakup, so it was nice to have a new addition to our group, though it would never be the same without Torquil and Devon.

29th November 1998
Former drummer Devon O'Connell subsequently agrees to rejoin the band, after turning down recent invitations to rejoin the group from August until late November. With three of the core members of back together, along with a fourth new member, the band felt that even if it wasn't a success, they would at least be able to record a new.

4th January 1999
This was the band's first official recording session for their thirteenth album. Gregory Dogan would serve as a co-producer for these recording sessions, with Chudley Maron serving as the band's music supervisor.

On this day the band recorded a new composition 'Mochaccino Springs' which was written by Sam Whitby, although both Peter and Sam later claimed that it was Peter who put together the ultimate version of the song, as well as contribute a lot of the music, though the initial draft of the lyrics were written solely by Sam.

Peter said that it was Sam's song, and that he may have put together the final draft of the song, and he may have contributed a lot of the music, but it was primarily his work, and it was his concept. The song was described as an attempt to write a song with a mild n flavour, but also with a dark and moody feel to it.

This would be the first recording by the band to feature Milford Ekdahl as a. Ironically even though Sam was the primary composer of the song, it was Peter that would serve as the song's co-producer along with Gregory Dogan.

8th January 1999
Session musicians Ivory Copenhaver, Elnora Jardine, and Ezra Wichman respectively add, , and  to 'Mochaccino Springs' on this day.

10th January 1999
Peter McDonald and session musicians Tracey Lessman, Ned Morphis, Emma Picou, and Morris Savala record overdubs while Ciera Batz, Royce Shoop, and Duncan Utsey record  overdubs for 'Mochaccino Springs' on this day.

11th January 1999
Peter McDonald records a for 'Mochaccino Springs' on this day, while Sam Whitby records a  and a   overdub. Sam's was also  on this day.

12th February 1999
The band recorded a new composition 'Ocean Ripple' on this day. It was written primarily by Peter McDonald, with input from Sam Whitby. This was the band's first recording to feature Milford Ekdahl on backing vocals.

19th February 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A dreamy song 'Mortar Skies' which was written solely by Peter McDonald.

27th February 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. 'Paintball Attendant' which was written solely by Sam Whitby. The song would become the titular track for the band's thirteenth album. Like 'Mochaccino Springs', 'Paintball Attendant' would feature Sam Whitby as the primary songwriter, but Peter McDonald as a co-producer.

4th March 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. 'Striped Cone' which was written solely by Sam Whitby.

18th March 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. 'Palette Knife' which was written primarily by Sam Whitby, with input from Milford Ekdahl. This was the first composition that would credit Milford as a cowriter.

21st March 1999
Peter McDonald double-tracks his lead vocals on 'Ocean Ripple' and 'Mortar Skies' on this day. Sam Whitby would do the same with his lead vocals on 'Paintball Attendant'.

It was during this same session that Sam records and double-tracks a backing vocal overdub for 'Ocean Ripple'. Devon O'Connell recorded overdubs for 'Ocean Ripple', 'Mortar Skies', 'Paintball Attendant', and 'Striped Cone'.

25th March 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Milford Ekdahl record overdubs for 'Paintball Attendant' on this day. It was during this same session that session musicians Eleonore Hinojos and Katy Taranto recorded overdubs, while Neal Nobriga and Tracey Lessman respectively recorded  and cello overdubs.

31st March 1999
Sam Whitby records a overdub for 'Mochaccino Springs' on this day. Peter McDonald was busy at the time so Sam seized the opportunity to record a bass guitar overdub using Peter's bass guitar for 'Mochaccino Springs' himself.

Sam later said that it wasn't exactly easy trying to play on Peter's bass guitar since Peter was right handed, as was his bass guitar. Sam was left handed, so trying to play on a right handed bass wasn't the easiest thing he'd ever done, but he managed it.

5th April 1999
Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby respectively record cello and overdubs for 'Ocean Ripple' on this day. They were joined by session musicians Leticia Angert, Eleonore Hinojos, and Katy Taranto who contributed violin overdubs, Jeremiah Dibernardo, Daryl Laffoon, and Neal Nobriga who contributed viola overdubs, Emma Picou and Morris Savala who contributed cello overdubs, Ciera Batz who contributed double bass overdubs, and Weston Montufar who contributed overdubs.

8th April 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and session musician Percy Duncan respectively record bass guitar,, and overdubs for 'Striped Cone' on this day.

13th April 1999
Devon O'Connell records himself blowing through a into a  with  to create a bubbling effect and adds it as an overdub to 'Ocean Ripple' on this day. The song was now completed.

It should be noted that there are two mixes of 'Ocean Ripple'. Both mixes use the same instrumentation, but the mix released as a single in the and most other countries, as well as on the UK album release of Paintball Arena has a slightly rawer and crisper sound, a more prominent electric piano, as well as more prominent percussion, and more prominent water bubbling, particularly during the final fade.

The mix released as a single in the and on the album release of Paintball Arena outside the UK has more a slightly fuller sound, and more prominent, although the remaining instrumentation in this mix is more balanced.

The mix released on most compilation albums from 2001 to 2010 is the one that was released as a single in the US and on the album release of 'Paintball Arena' outside the UK. The mix released on most compilation albums from 2011 onwards is the one that was released as a single in the UK and most other countries, as well as on the UK album release of 'Paintball Arena'.

18th April 1999
Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby record backing vocal and acoustic guitar overdubs for 'Mortar Skies' on this day. Devon O'Connell and Milford Ekdahl respectively record and acoustic guitar overdubs. Chudley Maron and Gregory Dogan respectively record electric piano and overdubs.

Session musicians Stacey Cuyler, Elnora Jardine, and Dino Tunison respectively record, tambura, and overdubs for 'Mortar Skies' during this same session. Session musicians Chauncey Dehoyos and Gregorio Wuensche recorded overdubs.

23rd April 1999
Peter McDonald records an overdub bass guitar for 'Mortar Skies' on this day. Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, Milford Ekdahl, Chudley Maron, and Gregory Dogan also recorded, s, , , and  overdubs.

4th May 1999
Peter McDonald records a overdub for 'Mortar Skies' on this day. The song was now completed.

9th May 1999
Peter McDonald and Milford Ekdahl respectively recorded and Lowrey organ overdubs for 'Palette Knife' on this day. Sam Whitby recorded backing vocal and electric piano overdubs while Chudley Maron and Gregory Dogan respectively recorded and  overdubs. This made 'Palette Knife' the first composition to feature either a hammered dulcimer and a Prophet-5, both which were featured on this track.

13th May 1999
The band recorded a cover version of '' which was written by who had passed away three days earlier. The band knew the song well before Shel's passing, but it certain that they had chosen to record their own version of the song as a sort of private tribute in his memory.

had recorded a version of the song more than a decade earlier, but  saw recording their own version of the song, which wasn't intended for immediate release as an opportunity to revisit the  style of some of their earlier songs, while taking a slight break from recording their thirteenth studio album which was already destined to become a  and  album.

19th May 1999
Devon O'Connell added some overdubs for certain parts of 'Mochaccino Springs' on this day, while Milford Ekdahl used a  for additional effects. If Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby weren't 100% satisfied with the master recording of 'Mochaccino Springs' before, they were almost certainly satisfied now. Sam Whitby later said that the opening and ending instrumentation and s were loosely inspired by 's ''. 'That's why the style of the song is somewhat darker than a lot of our other recordings' he said.

'But we had to keep the style to a minimum since it would have sounded out of place alongside the other songs that we recorded in 1999'. 'It also has a mild Indian flavour to it' added Peter 'And a psychedelic feel to it, which a Sisters of Mercy song would never have, so 'Mochaccino Springs' never really ended up sounding like The Sisters of Mercy, but we were looking at the instrumentation of 'No Time to Cry' when we decided how we were going to do 'Mochaccino Springs'.

It should be noted that there are two mixes of 'Mochaccino Springs'. Both mixes use the same instrumentation, but the mix released as a in the UK and most other countries, as well as on the UK album release of 'Paintball Arena' has a slightly rawer and crisper sound, more prominent, more prominent  sounds, and a more prominent , particularly during the final fade. The mix released as a single in the US and on the album release of 'Paintball Arena' outside the UK has a slightly fuller sound, more prominent strings, and a more prominent, although the remaining instrumentation in this mix is more balanced.

The mix released on most compilation albums from 2001 to 2010 is the one that was released as a single in the US and on the album release of 'Paintball Arena' outside the UK. The mix released on most compilation albums from 2011 onwards is the one that was released as a single in the UK and most other countries, as well as on the UK album release of 'Paintball Arena'.

23rd June 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A psychedelic rock song 'Stained Glass' which was written by Peter McDonald.

7th July 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A psychedelic rock song 'Mosaic Tiles' which was written primarily by Peter McDonald, with input from Milford Ekdahl.

13th July 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A and  song 'Craquelure' which was written primarily by Devon O'Connell, with input from Sam Whitby.

20th July 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A  song 'Diffuse Glow' which was written primarily by Devon O'Connell, with input from Peter McDonald.

25th July 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record, slide guitar, and overdubs for 'Mosaic Tiles' on this day.

27th July 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record acoustic guitar, electric guitar, drum kit, and acoustic guitar overdubs for 'Stained Glass' on this day.

30th July 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A  'Tie-Dyed Silk' which was written by Sam Whitby.

5th August 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record cello,, drum kit, and keyboard overdubs for 'Stained Glass' on this day. The song was now completed.

16th August 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A song 'Angled Strokes' which was written by Peter McDonald, but produced by Sam Whitby along with Gregory Dogan.

20th August 1999
Peter McDonald double-tracks his lead vocal for 'Angled Strokes' on this day.

25th September 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A pop rock song 'Polar Coordinates' which was written by primarily by Peter McDonald with input from Sam Whitby. Though the track would be produced by Sam Whitby and Gregory Dogan.

20th October 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. A  song 'Conté Crayon' which was written primarily by Devon O'Connell, with input from Sam Whitby.

10th November 1999
The band recorded a new composition on this day. An  song 'Charcoal Bubbles' which was written primarily by Sam Whitby, with input from Peter McDonald.

13th November 1999
Sam Whitby and Devon O'Connell respectively record vibraphone and percussion overdubs for 'Polar Coordinates' on this day.

16th November 1999
Peter McDonald recorded cello overdubs for 'Angled Strokes' on this day. He is joined by session musicians Leticia Angert, Tamar Crafts, Eleonore Hinojos, and Katy Taranto who contributed violin overdubs, Jeremiah Dibernardo and Daryl Laffoon who contributed viola overdubs, Emma Picou and Morris Savala who contributed cello overdubs, Duncan Utsey who contributed double bass overdubs, and Weston Montufar who contributed pedal harp overdubs.

20th November 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Milford Ekdahl record acoustic guitar overdubs for 'Craquelure' on this day.

22nd November 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record , tambura, maracas, and  overdubs for 'Diffuse Glow' on this day.

25th November 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record tambura, vibraphone, conga drums, and electric piano overdubs for 'Conté Crayon' on this day. Devon also recorded a backing vocal overdub and his lead vocal was also double-tracked.

27th November 1999
Peter McDonald and Devon O'Connell respectively record sitar and overdubs for 'Diffuse Glow' on this day.

28th November 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, Devon O'Connell, and Milford Ekdahl record for 'Conté Crayon' on this day.

30th November 1999
Sam Whitby and Milford Ekdahl respectively record  and slide guitar overdubs for 'Craquelure' on this day.

1st December 1999
Peter McDonald recorded cello overdubs for 'Craquelure' on this day. He was joined by session musicians Bob Brannon who contributed overdubs, Raphael Carnegie who contributed  overdubs, Tamar Crafts and Katy Taranto who contributed violin overdubs, Jeremiah Dibernardo who contributed viola overdubs, Kayla Haycock and Corliss Sancho who contributed  overdubs, and Gaylord Whelpley who contributed   overdubs.

Peter McDonald would also record cello overdubs for 'Tie-Dyed Silk' on this day. He was joined by session musicians Tamar Crafts and Katy Taranto who contributed violin overdubs, and Jeremiah Dibernardo who contributed viola overdubs.

2nd December 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Devon O'Connell recorded overdubs for 'Charcoal Bubbles' on this day. Peter recorded backing vocal and tambourine overdubs, Sam recorded harmony vocal and Lowrey organ overdubs, and Devon O'Connell recorded backing vocal, and overdubs.

3rd December 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Devon O'Connell respectively recorded s, backing vocal and maracas, and overdubs for 'Charcoal Bubbles' on this day.

4th December 1999
Peter McDonald, Sam Whitby, and Milford Ekdahl respectively record grand piano, rhythm guitar, and Lowrey organ overdubs for 'Conté Crayon' on this day.

5th December 1999
Peter McDonald and Sam Whitby respectively record electric piano and overdubs for 'Conté Crayon' on this day. They are joined by Wilburn Charboneau and Teodoro Orterga who record overdubs, Kayla Haycock and Corliss Sancho who record French horn overdubs, Erich Phong who recorded B♭ trumpet overdubs, and Reggie Valez who recorded  overdubs.

6th December 1999
Single Release — 'Mochaccino Springs' / 'Ocean Ripple'

7th December 1999
Devon O'Connell records overdubs of himself drawing with a for 'Conté Crayon' on this day.

Sam Whitby records overdubs of himself using to create a slicing noise for 'Palette Knife' on this day.

Peter McDonald records overdubs of himself brushing a against a wall to create a brushing noise for 'Angled Strokes' on this day.

Peter McDonald records overdubs of himself mixing to create an effect for 'Mortar Skies' on this day.

Devon O'Connell records Moog synthesiser overdubs for 'Diffuse Glow' on this day.

Peter McDonald records overdubs of himself wiping windows with a cloth for 'Stained Glass' on this day.

Peter McDonald records overdubs of himself making sound effects using s to create an effect for 'Mosaic Tiles' on this day.

Sam Whitby records overdubs of himself blowing bubbles for 'Charcoal Bubbles' on this day.

10th January 2000
Album release — Paintball Arena